So.. where even is the "Upload Feedback Thread"??

I’m told to come here because of course my edits got disapproved mainly due to the time limit of 3 days for review. 1 moderator did review it saying it had poor quality yet it actually is very similar to other Pit edits of the same style that made it through, so I have no clue why the Mods are both slow and finicky with what they let pass?

Because some people upload stuff to be reviewed and it just instantly gets approved it seems as well, so either I’m going crazy or it’s not worth uploading anything if I have to go through this confusing rigamarole :/

Here are my edits in question:
- post #88934
- post #88935

Here are some references for comparison:
- post #60322
- post #64308

Users with orange/green/pink usernames have their uploads autoapproved.

Tho I agree that a better explanation with the disapproval would be nice.
'Poor quality' in what way? Low resolution? Bad source image? Subpar edit(s)?

AryanSuperSoldier said:

I’m told to come here because of course my edits got disapproved mainly due to the time limit of 3 days for review. 1 moderator did review it saying it had poor quality yet it actually is very similar to other Pit edits of the same style that made it through, so I have no clue why the Mods are both slow and finicky with what they let pass?

Because some people upload stuff to be reviewed and it just instantly gets approved it seems as well, so either I’m going crazy or it’s not worth uploading anything if I have to go through this confusing rigamarole :/

Here are my edits in question:
- post #88934
- post #88935

Here are some references for comparison:
- post #60322
- post #64308

Mods are probably a bit slow nowadays, idk; aside from the obvious stuff that shouldn't be there, there's some good posts but they don't get approved within a few days unfortunately.
Low resolution is kind of a stretch, post #64308 got a pass and it's the same resolution as your edits. I don't know what bad source image would mean, I guess you get it off another site but it has varying qualities and the one you got doesn't have the "best" quality. Subpar edits: It's kind of ambigious since the first guy looks tan and I've seen tan dudes here so I don't get why it wasn't allowed but the second image, you'll probably have to lighten him up because he's bit darker than the first dude. I'm no mod or critic so that's basically my opinion and I'll say it again, I'm pretty colorblind.
I know how you feel because I might make some edits myself, even some edits on animations so you'll have to keep playing with the color settings until it looks natural. Basically trial and error. Though how does one do skin edits in animation, do I have to find photoshop/similar files of the original or if they don't have it, how do I dump frames of a video or gif? I heard FFMPEG can do it but I'm not sure because I only know FFMPEG because yt-dlp uses it.

BleachedAnon said:

Mods are probably a bit slow nowadays, idk; aside from the obvious stuff that shouldn't be there, there's some good posts but they don't get approved within a few days unfortunately.
Low resolution is kind of a stretch, post #64308 got a pass and it's the same resolution as your edits. I don't know what bad source image would mean, I guess you get it off another site but it has varying qualities and the one you got doesn't have the "best" quality. Subpar edits: It's kind of ambigious since the first guy looks tan and I've seen tan dudes here so I don't get why it wasn't allowed but the second image, you'll probably have to lighten him up because he's bit darker than the first dude. I'm no mod or critic so that's basically my opinion and I'll say it again, I'm pretty colorblind.
I know how you feel because I might make some edits myself, even some edits on animations so you'll have to keep playing with the color settings until it looks natural. Basically trial and error. Though how does one do skin edits in animation, do I have to find photoshop/similar files of the original or if they don't have it, how do I dump frames of a video or gif? I heard FFMPEG can do it but I'm not sure because I only know FFMPEG because yt-dlp uses it.

I made my edits in GiMP which is why the colour edits are so iffy. It’s also hard for me to lighten up the skin tone of the guy because of the way Pit draws his Niggers and shading, if I lightened them either of them anymore than I already have them then the dude being edited would’ve lost all shading and it would’ve just looked like a weird pale thing pounding a Bimbo.

I could probably try and make it better, but again idk if there’s a point considering the mods are so slow to respond, and I still have no answers for the main question. Where the hell is the “Upload Feedback Thread”? Also I’m tan, like as tan as the first edit which is why I thought it was good enough, because other edits and posts on Bleachbooru also have white guys with tans like that, so I figured I could make the guy as light as this whilst still retaining the cell shading and contrasts/textures etc. idk, apparently mods know better yet none of them have responded personally or publicly here.

AryanSuperSoldier said:

I made my edits in GiMP which is why the colour edits are so iffy. It’s also hard for me to lighten up the skin tone of the guy because of the way Pit draws his Niggers and shading, if I lightened them either of them anymore than I already have them then the dude being edited would’ve lost all shading and it would’ve just looked like a weird pale thing pounding a Bimbo.

I could probably try and make it better, but again idk if there’s a point considering the mods are so slow to respond, and I still have no answers for the main question. Where the hell is the “Upload Feedback Thread”? Also I’m tan, like as tan as the first edit which is why I thought it was good enough, because other edits and posts on Bleachbooru also have white guys with tans like that, so I figured I could make the guy as light as this whilst still retaining the cell shading and contrasts/textures etc. idk, apparently mods know better yet none of them have responded personally or publicly here.

I mean, I do see some relatively tan dudes on here, even tans a bit darker than the average surfer dude, still don't see why it's not accepted when it's true that dudes will darken up more under the sun than girls. White dudes are pretty darker than their female counterpants because of more T than women's, skin thickness, and whatnot so I see why.
Also his art style from what I've seen isn't even stylized, looks pretty realistic (not like full blown realism but proportions are kind of realistic like anime's proportions but I'm no art critic) either so I understand why it's a risky move so I suggest you make the second guy more like the first one though you don't have to: it's your edit so go wild, I think the only time actual paleness will work in art is if the art style is more stylized like it has a cartoony/simple art style to it or maybe the dude's a vampire or he's in the cold for so long.
Closest thing I found to a Upload Feedback Thread is this one: topic #219. It's dead but I guess it could help or you can make one.
Like I said before, I'm not a mod or critic so take it with grains of salt.

Accidentally put forum instead of topic, also idk about Krita but you could try that. My advice: Mess with art programs until you find one that works good enough.